|           St. Johns                 |          Butler    |
|
| Player | PPG | Year | | 5 Kelvin Odih | | FR | | 17 Ruben Prey | | SO | | 6 Casper Pohto | | FR | | 7 Fotis Konstantinidis | | FR | | 22 Imran Suljanovic | | FR |
| | Player | PPG | Year | | 5 Michael Ajayi | | SR | | 1 Evan Haywood | | SO | | 4 Efeosa Oliogu-Elabor | | FR | | 35 Bryson Cardinal | | FR | | 39 Kevin Ndzie | | JR |
|
|
| Game Date | Matchup | Score | Location | Cume Win Prob | | 01/04/2025 | Butler @ St. Johns | 62 - 70 | Carnesecca Arena | 0.785 | | 02/26/2025 | St. Johns @ Butler | 76 - 70 | Hinkle Fieldhouse | 0.212 | | 03/13/2025 | Butler @ St. Johns | 57 - 78 | Madison Square Garden | 0.978 | | 01/02/2024 | Butler @ St. Johns | 70 - 86 | Carnesecca Arena | 0.929 | | 02/28/2024 | St. Johns @ Butler | 82 - 59 | Hinkle Fieldhouse | 0.078 |
|